From Idea to Algorithm: Backtesting Strategies that Work#

Why Backtest?#

• Objective Assessment: It reduces guesswork by providing measurable performance metrics.
• Strategy Comparison: Backtesting allows you to compare different strategies on a consistent basis.
• Risk Analysis: Drawdowns, volatility, and other risk measures come to the forefront.
• Efficiency: Testing several years of data programmatically is less resource-intensive than forward testing in real time.

Limitations#

• Past Performance ?Future Results: Markets evolve, and strategies that worked well in certain market phases can fail later.
• Data Bias: Poor data quality leads to misleading results.
• Overfitting: Excessively tweaking parameters to fit historical data can ruin out-of-sample performance.

Sources of Market Data#

1. Data Vendors: Paid services like Bloomberg, Thomson Reuters, or smaller specialized vendors.
2. Free Sources: Yahoo Finance, Alpha Vantage, or certain cryptocurrency exchange APIs.
3. Broker APIs: Many brokers provide historical data for their clients.

Data Format and Contents#

A typical dataset might look like this:

Each row represents a time periodhere, daily bars with open, high, low, close (OHLC) values and trading volume.

Cleaning Your Data#

1. Check for Missing Values: Some data points may be missing or recorded incorrectly.
2. Adjust for Splits and Dividends: Stock prices need adjustment to reflect corporate actions.
3. Time Alignment: Ensure all instruments and benchmarks share a common timeline.
4. Outliers: Confirm that any extreme values in price or volume are real and not data errors.

Resampling#

If you have 1-minute data but your strategy operates on daily bars, youll need to resample. Properly resampling data is essential for accurate calculations. For instance, a daily OHLC bar derived from 1-minute data has its own intricacies (like capturing the correct open and close times).

Strategy Styles#

• Trend-Following: Seeks to capitalize on market momentum (e.g., moving average crossovers).
• Mean Reversion: Buys oversold conditions and sells overbought conditions, expecting the price to revert to its mean.
• Arbitrage: Exploits price differences in related markets or instruments.
• Event-Driven: Trades around earnings announcements, mergers, or macroeconomic data releases.

Risk Management as a Core Design Element#

Risk management is not just a second thought; its integral. Determine your maximum allowable drawdown or risk tolerance from the outset. Incorporate position sizing rules, stop losses, and trailing stops. Design your strategy to handle unexpected market conditions, like flash crashes or major liquidity events.

Step-by-Step Outline#

1. Import Libraries
2. Load Data
3. Generate Signals
4. Simulate Trades
5. Calculate Performance Metrics

Below is a simplified example:

1
import pandas as pd
2

3
# 1. Load the data
4
data = pd.read_csv("price_data.csv", parse_dates=["Date"], index_col="Date")
5

6
# 2. Generate signals (example: simple rule - go long if today's close is above yesterday's close)
7
data["Signal"] = 0
8
data["Signal"] = (data["Close"] > data["Close"].shift(1)).astype(int)
9

10
# 3. Calculate daily returns
11
data["Strategy_Return"] = data["Signal"].shift(1) * (data["Close"].pct_change())
12

13
# 4. Accumulate returns over time
14
data["Cumulative_Return"] = (1 + data["Strategy_Return"]).cumprod()
15

16
# 5. Print some stats
17
print(f"Final return: {data['Cumulative_Return'].iloc[-1] - 1:.2%}")

Observations:

• We used the shift function so that we place trades on the following days open or close. This prevents look-ahead bias.
• We computed a simple daily return using Close.pct_change(). Realistic scenarios might involve slippage, commissions, and trades executed at the open.

Interpreting These Metrics#

• High Sharpe Ratio: Indicates good risk-adjusted returns, but strategies with high volatility may artificially inflate or deflate the ratio.
• Drawdown: If your strategy has a deep drawdown, it might be psychologically (or financially) difficult to follow, even if it recovers.
• Trade Distribution: Looking at the distribution of trade outcomes can reveal if a few large wins skews the results or if returns are consistent.

The Importance of a Benchmark#

Its often necessary to compare your strategy against a benchmark (like the S&P 500). If your strategy underperforms that benchmark in both returns and risk-adjusted returns, it may not be worthwhile.

Strategy Logic#

• Short-Term SMA: Compute moving average of closing prices over a short window (e.g., 20 days).
• Long-Term SMA: Compute a longer moving average (e.g., 50 days).
• Buy Signal: Occurs when the short-term SMA crosses above the long-term SMA.
• Sell Signal: Occurs when the short-term SMA crosses back below the long-term SMA.

Sample Code#

1
import pandas as pd
2
import numpy as np
3

4
# 1. Load data
5
data = pd.read_csv("price_data.csv", parse_dates=["Date"], index_col="Date")
6

7
# 2. Calculate SMAs
8
short_window = 20
9
long_window = 50
10
data["SMA_Short"] = data["Close"].rolling(window=short_window).mean()
11
data["SMA_Long"] = data["Close"].rolling(window=long_window).mean()
12

13
# 3. Generate signals: 1 for buy, 0 for out
14
data["Signal"] = 0
15
data["Signal"][short_window:] = np.where(
16
    data["SMA_Short"][short_window:] > data["SMA_Long"][short_window:], 1, 0
17
)
18

19
# 4. Create trading positions by taking the difference of signals
20
data["Position"] = data["Signal"].diff()
21

22
# 5. Calculate returns
23
data["Strategy_Return"] = data["Signal"].shift(1) * data["Close"].pct_change()
24

25
# 6. Accumulate returns over time
26
data["Cumulative_Strategy"] = (1 + data["Strategy_Return"]).cumprod()
27
data["Cumulative_Benchmark"] = (1 + data["Close"].pct_change()).cumprod()
28

29
# 7. Final performance
30
final_strategy_return = data["Cumulative_Strategy"].iloc[-1] - 1
31
final_benchmark_return = data["Cumulative_Benchmark"].iloc[-1] - 1
32

33
print(f"Strategy Return: {final_strategy_return:.2%}")
34
print(f"Benchmark Return: {final_benchmark_return:.2%}")

Analysis#

• The simple moving average crossover tends to work well in trending markets but can suffer in choppy, sideways markets.
• Adjusting parameters (e.g., different window sizes) can yield different outcomes, but be wary of overfitting to historical data.

8.1 Transaction Costs and Slippage#

Real markets have costslike broker commissions, spreads, and slippage:

• Commission: Fee paid per transaction or per share/contract.
• Slippage: The difference between your intended order price and the actual execution price, especially crucial in high-frequency or large-quantity trading.

In code, you might deduct these costs from each executed trade:

1
commission_per_trade = 5.00
2
slippage_factor = 0.0001  # 0.01% slippage
3

4
trade_price = data["Close"][i]
5
slippage_cost = trade_price * slippage_factor
6
execution_price = trade_price + slippage_cost if going_long else trade_price - slippage_cost
7
net_trade_return = (execution_price_next_day - execution_price) / execution_price - (commission_per_trade / trade_price)

8.2 Walk-Forward Analysis#

Instead of using the entire data series to optimize parameters (like SMA window sizes), you break the historical period into smaller segmentswalk-forward?windows. You optimize in one segment and test those parameters on the following segment. This process more accurately simulates real-world trading life cycles.

8.3 Overfitting and Proper Validation#

Overfitting occurs when your strategy becomes too closely tailored to past data. To mitigate this:

• Use Out-of-Sample Data: Split your dataset into training and testing periods. Avoid making decisions based on the test period.
• Cross-Validation: If feasible, re-test your strategy in different time segments or different market regimes.
• Keep it Simple: Complex strategies with many parameters have a higher risk of overfitting.

8.4 Position Sizing and Portfolio Construction#

Position sizing goes beyond a simple approach of all-in?or all-out.?Techniques include:

• Volatility Scaling: Scale position sizes inversely proportional to recent volatility.
• Equal Weighting: In a multi-asset portfolio, allocate equal amounts of capital to each strategy or asset.
• Risk Parity: Allocate capital in proportion to risk contributions from each asset.

9.1 Multi-Asset Backtesting#

Rather than testing a single asset, you could build a portfolio of global equities, bonds, commodities, or cryptocurrencies. Focus on:

• Correlation Analysis: Understand how assets behave together. Highly correlated assets might amplify portfolio volatility.
• Rebalancing: Define how often you rebalance your portfolio to maintain target allocations.
• Hedging Strategies: Evaluate options or futures positions to reduce downside risk.

9.2 Factor Investing and Machine Learning#

Beyond standard technical indicators, advanced practitioners often employ factor models or machine learning:

• Factor Models: Identify systematic risk factors (e.g., value, momentum, quality).
• Machine Learning: Use classification or regression models (Random Forest, XGBoost, neural networks) to predict returns or classify signals.
• Feature Engineering: Derive new features (volatility, volume changes, fundamental ratios) to enhance predictive power.

9.3 Survivorship Bias-Free Data#

When testing equity strategies, some companies delist or merge. If you only use currently listed stocks, youre ignoring those that went bankrupt or were delisted in the past. This is survivorship bias.?Use data that includes dead or delisted securities to provide a more realistic historical simulation.

9.4 Out-of-Sample Testing and Monte Carlo Analysis#

To further pressure-test your strategy:

• Out-of-Sample: Reserve a chunk of data to measure performance after you have finalized your strategy rules on training data.
• Monte Carlo Simulation: Randomly reshuffle or sample your returns in different sequences to gauge the range of possible outcomes.

9.5 Stress Testing#

Create hypothetical scenarios (like a 2008-style financial crisis or a flash crash) to see how your strategy would respond. For instance, forcibly drop the asset price by a fixed percentage on a given date and see how your algorithm behaves.

9.6 Algorithmic Execution Considerations#

Professional-level backtesting tries to approximate real execution closely:

• Order Book Simulation: If youre dealing in high-frequency strategies, you need to simulate the order book, partial fills, and market microstructure.
• Latency and Market Impact: Large orders can move the market, particularly in less liquid assets.